We use cookies to give you the best possible online experience. By clicking Close you indicate that you are happy for your web browser to receive all cookies from our website including cookies that are linked to your personally identifiable information. See our cookie policy for more information on cookies and how to manage them.

Tech centre - Financial planning bulletin

ISA or Pension?

May 4, 2018, 16:59 PM

Summary


Although never the starting point for investment choice, the tax wrapper is nevertheless an important part in determining the overall investment return.

The decision between choosing an ISA or a pension will often come down to how and when an individual is likely to want to access the investment.  The introduction of pensions flexibility in 2015 and flexible ISAs in 2016 are therefore important factors in the decision between an ISA or pension wrapper.

In this bulletin we will compare the tax treatment of each, and consider the implications of pensions flexibility and flexible ISAs and how those changes impact on the choice between a pension and an ISA for a client.

Facts and analysis


On pure tax grounds when there is tax relief on the contributions, it is difficult to beat a pension. This is particularly the case for someone who is a higher rate taxpayer when making the pension contribution, but a basic rate taxpayer when they take the benefits.  More is invested which means that the pension may benefit from growth on the tax relief, and it is invested in a tax efficient fund.  When benefits are taken 25% is normally available as tax free cash, with the remainder taxable at the individual’s marginal rate.

An ISA also invests in a tax efficient fund, and although there is no tax relief on the contributions, all of the benefits are free of tax.

Let’s consider examples for basic and higher rate taxpayers –

  • Assuming an initial investment of £10,000 and a net return of 4% per annum after charges
  • Whole fund is taken as a lump sum after 10 years of investment

Investment wrapper

Initial investment

Value after 10 years

Tax free cash

Taxable Lump sum net of tax

Total Net Return

ISA - regardless of tax rate paid

£10,000

£14,802

-

-

£14,802

Pension - basic rate taxpayer

£12,500*

£18,503

£4,626

£11,102

£15,728

Pension - higher rate taxpayer at the start and basic rate taxpayer when taking benefits

£16,667**

£24,671

£6,168

£14,802

£20,970

*Net contribution of £10,000, plus tax relief at the basic rate of £2,500

**Net contribution of £13,333, plus tax relief at the basic rate of £3,333.  Client also reclaims £3,333 higher rate tax relief

The table illustrates that when you compare the 3 scenarios the pension will deliver the highest post tax return.  There are, of course, other scenarios that you could consider, including that an individual could receive basic rate tax relief on the contribution, and then because the benefits are taken as a lump sum, that some is taxed at higher rates of tax.  For example, if the basic rate taxpayer ends up taking the full taxable lump sum of £13,877 while still working full time and half of it falls into the higher rate tax band, the ISA would have been more tax efficient.

When choosing the best tax wrapper for an investment for a client, however, tax is not the only consideration.  A pension is often not chosen on the basis of lack of access or because the investment is just not considered ‘retirement money’.

Pensions flexibility has gone some way to addressing issues of accessibility.  For a client who is looking for a longer term investment, with no access to at least part of that investment prior to age 55, a pension should be considered along side ISAs as a suitable tax wrapper.

There are, however, a couple of important points to consider - 

  • Pensions can currently be accessed from age 55, but this is set to increase to age 57 in 2028 (when the State Pension age rises to 67), and then increase in line with changes to the State Pension age
  • If a member flexibly accesses any taxable income from their pension this will restrict the amount of any future pension contributions.  The money purchase annual allowance was £10,000 in 2016/17 and reduced to £4,000 in 2018/19.  

Flexible ISAs enable an individual to take money out of the investment wrapper and then replace it.  Prior to 6 April 2016 if a member needed to access money from their ISA the money could not be replaced unless there was some of the annual limit still remaining.  Since 6 April 2016 an investor can replace money they have withdrawn from their ISA earlier in a tax year.  For example, your client paid in £20,000 on 6 April 2018, but due to a subsequent emergency they needed access to £10,000 on 1 July 2018.  The client will have until 5 April 2019 to replace the £10,000 in the Flexible ISA wrapper without affecting their normal annual limit.  Please note that not all ISAs will offer this flexibility.

Example

Mr and Mrs Collins are age 60 and both still working full time. They both have pensions with a total value of £500,000 and ISAs totalling £200,000.

They are about to move house to be closer to their daughter and new grandchild, and have found the perfect new home.  They are in the fortunate position of having no mortgage, and are going to use the proceeds from the sale of their house to buy the new house valued at £200,000.

A couple of weeks before the move their own house purchase is delayed due to one of the buyers in the chain dropping out.  It is thought that the chain will eventually proceed and their house will be sold, but unfortunately the owners of the house they want to buy are going to put it back onto the market unless they stick to the originally agreed sale date.  Mr and Mrs Collins are keen to avoid taking out a bridging loan if possible and would prefer to use existing savings.

As both Mr and Mrs Collins are aged 60 it means that they can access their pensions.  To reach the total of £200,000 they would need to take the maximum tax free cash of £125,000 plus a taxable lump sum for the balance.  The amount of the lump sum will depend on the marginal rate of tax they will pay, but as they are both in full time employment it is likely that some of the lump sum will be taxable at the higher rates of tax.

This will generate the cash required to secure the new house purchase.  There is then the issue of how to reinvest the funds received from the sale of their own house when this proceeds.  If they have flexibly accessed the taxable income from their pension it means that the money purchase annual allowance will apply, which limits any future pension contributions.  Consideration would also need to be given to the tax free cash recycling rules.  This is going to make it very difficult to replace the funds into the pension.

Alternatively they could use the funds from their ISAs.  If their existing ISA is not a flexible ISA they will need firstly to transfer it to a provider who does offer the flexibility.  They can then withdraw the funds they need to secure the purchase of the new house.  On the sale of their own house, they pay the full £200,000 back into the Flexible ISA so long as this all takes place within the same tax year.  In addition they will still have the balance of any available annual limit for the tax year. Care would need to be taken that there is a clear expectation that the house sale will proceed within the same tax year so that the ISA funds can be replaced in full.

Next steps


The tax story for a pension is fairly compelling for many people, especially those who are higher and additional rate taxpayers.  A pension is also an attractive tax wrapper from an IHT perspective.  Whilst an ISA will form part of the investor’s estate on death, the pension will normally be free of any tax charge on death prior to age 75, and taxable at marginal rates of tax on death age 75 and above.

An ISA, and particularly a Flexible ISA, whilst not as tax efficient in many cases, does offer more flexibility to the client.  As illustrated above, if a client is in desperate need of a large taxable lump sum from a pension this could trigger higher rates of tax on the payment, and result in a less tax efficient return than an ISA.

Learning outcomes and reflective questions for CII accredited CPD


Reading this article can count towards structured CPD under the CII CPD Scheme if you consider the Learning Objectives below to be directly relevant to your own personal professional development plan. The Reflective Questions don’t require answering, they are aimed to help you reflect on the issues raised in the article for your reflective statement on your CPD Certificate.

Learning objectives:

  • To compare the tax treatment of a pension and an ISA
  • To understand the different access rules for pensions and ISAs
  • To consider whether a pension or ISA is the most appropriate investment wrapper for a client scenario;

Reflective questions:

  • Is a pension or an ISA going to be the best investment wrapper for my client?
  • Is my client likely to want the features that a flexibile ISA offers?

Important information


This information has not been approved for use with customers and is based on Aviva’s interpretation of current law and legislation, and our understanding of HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) practice as at 6 April 2018.  It is provided for general information purposes only and should not be relied upon in place of legal or other professional advice.  Both the law and HMRC practice will change from time to time and our interpretation may be subject to challenge by HMRC or other regulatory body. Aviva cannot act as legal adviser for you or your clients.  You should always seek appropriate legal or other professional advice.

Aviva Tech Centre

Protection planning

Umbrellas
Our protection articles can help support your financial planning process and offer the opportunity to earn CPD hours. Find out more

Aviva Tech Centre

Pension planning

Family and dog
Pension planning articles looking at pre-retirement, benefits in retirement and death benefits. Find out more

Aviva Tech Centre

Investments and tax planning

Dolls house
A range of investment planning solutions covering personal and business investments. Find out more

Aviva Tech Centre

Trust and inheritance tax planning

Family on beach
Financial planning opportunities giving you information about inheritance tax and trust planning. Find out more

Back to top